Opening a demat account today takes a few minutes on a mobile phone, and advertisements, social media and friends’ success stories make trading in shares look easy. Many first-time market participants start buying and selling shares within weeks of opening an account. Before you do, it is worth understanding what stock trading actually involves, what it costs, and what the evidence says about how most traders fare.
Also available in: हिन्दी | मराठी
Key takeaways
- Investing means owning good businesses for years; trading means trying to profit from price movements over days, hours or minutes. They are very different activities.
- SEBI’s own study found that more than 70% of individual intraday traders in the equity cash segment made losses in FY 2022-23.
- Brokerage, taxes and other charges are paid on every trade, win or lose, and they add up quickly for frequent traders.
- Trading profits can be taxed as business income at your slab rate, not at the lower rates that apply to long-term investors.
- Never trade with borrowed money, your emergency fund or money needed for near-term goals.
Investing and trading are not the same thing
When you invest in a share, you buy part-ownership of a business because you expect its earnings, and therefore its value, to grow over several years. Your return comes mainly from the growth of the business and from dividends.
When you trade, you buy and sell over a much shorter period, hoping to profit from price movements. The quality of the business matters less than the direction of the price in the next few days or hours. Trading usually takes three forms:
- Intraday trading: buying and selling the same share on the same day. Positions not closed by the end of the day are squared off automatically by the broker.
- Swing trading: holding a position for a few days or weeks to catch a short-term move.
- Short-term delivery trading: buying shares into your demat account and selling within a few weeks or months.
Over short periods, share prices are driven heavily by news, sentiment and the actions of large, well-informed participants. That makes short-term price movements very hard to predict consistently, even for professionals.
What the data shows
In July 2024, SEBI published a study of individual intraday traders in the equity cash segment. It found that more than seven out of ten individual intraday traders made net losses in FY 2022-23, and that the proportion of loss-makers was even higher among those who traded most frequently. The study also found that trading costs formed a significant part of traders’ losses, and that a large share of intraday traders were young people under 30.
The lesson is not that nobody makes money from trading. Some people do. It is that the majority of individuals who try it lose money, and there is no reliable way to know in advance which group you will fall into.
The costs you pay on every trade
Every buy and sell order carries charges, whether the trade makes money or not. These include:
- Brokerage: many brokers advertise zero brokerage on delivery trades, but most charge a fee per order on intraday trades.
- Securities Transaction Tax (STT): currently 0.1% on both buying and selling for delivery trades, and 0.025% on the sell side for intraday trades.
- Exchange transaction charges, SEBI fees and stamp duty on each trade.
- GST at 18% on brokerage and transaction charges.
- Depository (DP) charges each time you sell shares from your demat account.
For a long-term investor who buys a few times a year, these costs are small. For someone who trades several times a day, they can add up to a large share of the capital over a year. A trader therefore needs to earn enough just to cover costs before making any real profit. Your broker’s contract note shows the full charges for every trade; read it.
How trading profits are taxed
The tax treatment depends on how you trade, and it is less favourable for frequent traders:
- Delivery trades held up to 12 months: short-term capital gains are taxed at 20%.
- Delivery trades held more than 12 months: long-term capital gains are taxed at 12.5% on gains above ₹1.25 lakh in a year, combined across listed shares and equity mutual funds.
- Intraday trading: treated as speculative business income and taxed at your income tax slab rate. Speculative losses can be set off only against speculative income.
- Very frequent delivery trading: if trading is your regular activity, the tax department may treat it as business income rather than capital gains.
Business income usually means filing a more detailed tax return, and above certain turnover limits a tax audit may be required. If you trade actively, consult a chartered accountant before the end of the financial year.
Why most traders lose
- Unequal competition. Individual traders compete with institutions, proprietary trading desks and algorithms that have faster technology, better information and lower costs.
- Costs. Frequent trading means costs are paid many times over.
- Emotions. Fear and greed lead people to sell winners too early, hold losing positions too long and trade more after a loss to win it back.
- Tips and “finfluencers”. Stock tips on social media, Telegram and WhatsApp groups are often unreliable and sometimes part of pump-and-dump schemes, where the promoters sell after followers buy.
- Overconfidence after early wins. A few lucky trades in a rising market can feel like skill, encouraging larger positions just before a fall.
If you still want to trade: essential safeguards
- Get your foundations in place first: an emergency fund, adequate health and term insurance, and regular long-term investments for your goals.
- Use only surplus money you can afford to lose entirely, and set a limit, such as a small percentage of your overall portfolio. Do not add to it after losses.
- Never trade with borrowed money. Avoid personal loans, credit cards and the margin trading facility (MTF) offered by brokers; borrowing magnifies losses and adds interest costs.
- Deal only through a SEBI-registered broker, keep your login details private, and never let anyone else operate your account.
- Ignore unsolicited tips. Anyone offering stock recommendations for a fee must be registered with SEBI as an investment adviser or research analyst. Check registration on the SEBI website.
- Decide your exit before you enter, including the loss at which you will sell, and stick to it.
- Keep a record of every trade, including costs, and review your actual results honestly after six months. If you are losing money overall, stop.
A better approach for most people
For most working people, building wealth through the stock market does not require trading at all. Regular, long-term investing in diversified equity mutual funds or index funds through a SIP gives you a share in the growth of many businesses, with professional management, low costs and lighter taxation for long-term holdings. It also takes far less time and causes far less stress. If you enjoy following companies, consider buying shares of a few well-run businesses for the long term, rather than trading them. See why small investors should prefer mutual funds over shares and mutual funds for beginners.
Frequently asked questions
Can I make a regular monthly income from stock trading?
A small minority of experienced, well-capitalised traders do, but SEBI’s data shows that most individual traders lose money. Treating trading as a source of regular income is very risky, particularly if you depend on it to meet household expenses.
Is intraday trading riskier than delivery trading?
Generally, yes. Intraday traders must be right about price movements within a single day, trade more often, pay costs more frequently, and are often offered leverage by brokers, which magnifies losses.
How much money do I need to start trading?
There is no minimum, but the more important question is how much you can afford to lose. Only use money that is genuinely surplus after your emergency fund, insurance and goal-based investments are taken care of.
Where can I complain about a broker?
First complain to the broker in writing. If the issue is not resolved, you can use SEBI’s SCORES portal at scores.sebi.gov.in or the exchange’s online dispute resolution (ODR) mechanism.
Related reading: mutual funds vs direct equity, guidelines for long-term investors, and how to build an emergency fund.
Disclaimer: This article is for general educational purposes only and is based on publicly available rules and data as of November 2026, which may change. It is not investment or tax advice, and it does not recommend any security. Trading in shares involves substantial risk of loss. Please consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser or a chartered accountant before making decisions.


