ETFs or Exchange Traded Funds have been gaining popularity in India for several years. ETFs offer some advantages over actively managed Mutual Funds, chiefly lower costs and transparent, rules-based portfolios, but they also suffer from some limitations:
1. Liquidity: ETFs are bought and sold over a stock Exchange. If a particular ETF is not widely traded, it may become difficult to sell the units at a price close to NAV, and the seller may have to accept a discount. It is wise to check trading volumes and the bid-ask spread of an ETF before purchase.
2. Demat Account: The investor needs a demat and trading account with a Depository Participant (DP) and stock broker to buy, hold and sell ETF units, and brokerage and other transaction charges apply.
3. International ETFs: When Indian residents buy ETFs listed on overseas exchanges through a foreign broker, the units are held with that broker, so the broker’s financial strength and the investor-protection rules of that country matter. Such investments also fall under the RBI’s Liberalised Remittance Scheme and must be disclosed in the foreign assets schedule of your income tax return.
4. Dividend Taxation: Dividends received from overseas ETFs may be subject to withholding tax in the country where the ETF is listed, and are also taxable in India at your slab rate, with credit for foreign tax available in some cases under the relevant tax treaty.
Index funds, which are bought and redeemed directly with the fund house at NAV, overcome some of these limitations, particularly the need for a demat account and the liquidity concern.
Related reading: index funds and ETFs explained, and index funds in India: how they work.


